Article:		Combining RELAX NG and Schematron
Subject:		Schematron+relax ng article
Date:		2004-02-14 00:32:54
From:		Dave Pawson
1. Page 2, you say embed Schematron rules at the top level, then don't do it. 2. Which version of schematron please? 3. Why such a long complex example, why not focus on the issue being discussed, not the instance validation. 4. No links to the command line Schematron stylesheet you use.

Previous Message

Next Message

• Schematron+relax ng article
  2004-02-14 03:50:32 Eddie Robertsson [Reply]
  
  Hi Dave,

  
  Answer to 1:
  The reason I included this option is because if you do it this way you have all the validation specified in one schema. You can of course have one RNG schema and then a separate Schematron schema and do each validation separate.

  
  Answer 2:
  I've used Schematron 1.5 but 1.6 and ISO Schematron should work as well.

  
  Answer 3:
  I realize that the examples are a bit complicated but I believe instance validation is part of the issue as well. I thought it would be hard to understand the actual validation process without an example.

  
  Answer 4:
  Hmm, in the original article I had a link to zip file with all the examples, stylesheets and java code. It seems it's gone missing so I appologize for this. I'll check with the xml.com people and see if they can add it. In the meantime you can download the zip file here:
  http://w1.461.comhem.se/~u46131175/xml/schematron/RNG_Schtrn.zip